“Steve.museum: An Ongoing Experiment in Social Tagging, Folksonomy, and Museums” is a paper written by Susan Chun, Doug Hiwiller, Jennifer Trant and Bruce Wyman. I read it today. I already had seen the presentation of steve.museum at the collaborative web tagging workshop and started a collaborative tagging application for museums myself.
The paper introduce the idea of using tagging as an indexation and catalogisation system for museums artworks. According to their “proof of concept” data, 80% of the terms used in tagging artworks through their prototype were new terms, meaning that they did not appear in annotations of the artwork before.
One quote I enjoyed a lot:
Tagging appeals because it represents a dialogue between the viewer and the work…
It is very true indeed, what else better than language to express ourselves, what else better than terms to describe things. This fits with our definition of tagging (see previous posts) in which the tagging process is viewed as a process of sharing knowledge through the transcription of observations.
Although the design the introduce in the paper (this was the last year’s paper, so the design might have change in between) seems rather unclear. It goes into different descriptions of possible relationships between users, “tags” and images or objects…
Antoher point of difficulty, it looks like they wish to automatize the inclusion process of artworks, meaning having some tools to directly export a museum database to the system, well that’s great, if it is feasable. I would rather create a system in which you add artworks by hand (like in del.icio.us), and add automatic systems for large museums(which can be done separately and specifically). Otherwise the small museums will never get there…
They also seem very concerned by the way to atract people to tag. Making games, interactive, showing the gift of tagging to the community… Well I believe it has to be useful so that people tag. Useful directly for them, as in del.icio.us, or flickr.
Otherwise it was a nice paper to read, refreshing my mind and giving me confidence in the design we started. I wish steve.museum to grow…